Hello Judges! The x2ftp game competition is a little bit late. We have virus-checked _almost_ all the material, and now it is your turn to start work. We will finish the elimination round 2 as soon as possible, but we have no more time to spare! Let the elimination round 3 begin! You will find the programs in /pub/msdos/programming/contest-directory sorted by category. The rules (by Jouni Miettunen, whereever he is now..) say: "We try to give feedback for each entry. In the first round we tell privately, why the entry was disqualified and try to suggest possible changes to make it acceptable. In the second round we give privately a short review of the entries and suggest ways of improvement. In the third round we make publicly available long reviews about the winners." Now it is Your turn to make this happen. Make a short review of the programs. Tell what is new, tell what was old, tell if something is shamelessly ripped from another game, tell, what you think is worth of more developing work! To make the final ranking easier to calculate, use following format in your replies: -------------------------------cut here---8<------------------------------- JUDGE: (your full email address) CATEGORY: (game_by_one,game_by_team..) PROGRAM: (from accepted-list) FILE NAME: (zipfile name, for identification) IDEA: ( Number between 1 and 5. Decide, if the game idea is good. Would you buy the game, if it had been made with bigger budget? Don't give full 5 stars too easily!) IMPLEMENTATION: (number between 1 and 5. Does the game work? Does it give an professional impression? Is it fast or good enough?) COMMENTS: ... (What made you to decide the number of the stars. We need your comments about playability, special effects, sound, graphics, and idea. Give the detailed info of IDEA: and IMPLEMENTATION:-sections here. If you have some visions or suggestions for further development, put them here. ---------------------------8<------------------------------------------------- You can send all the entries evaluated in a same mail. We calculate the final results and put all the comments together. Use all the time you need, but we have our internal deadline of _ASAP_. We will inform the judges and sponsors of the situation periodically, as soon as the first results arrives. IMPORTANT: If you are unable to do your job, please inform us immediately. There are some impressive masterpieces among the entries. Have fun, and remember, there are people waiting for results out there :-/ . /Antero Metso x2ftp.oulu.fi, Unix system adm. Results, and everything else: x2ftp@x2ftp.oulu.fi The judges-list: judges@x2ftp.oulu.fi