From: danny@cs.su.oz.au (Danny Yee) Date: Fri, 14 Apr 1995 13:20:41 +1000 Subject: Book Review - The Wet and the Dry title: The Wet and the Dry : Irrigation and Agricultural Intensification in Polynesia by: Patrick Vinton Kirch publisher: University of Chicago Press 1994 subjects: archaeology, anthropology, agriculture, Polynesia other: 385 pages, b&w illustrations, bibliography, index, US$49.95 summary: the longue duree in Polynesian agriculture Kirch's _The Evolution of the Polynesian Chiefdoms_ was a study of the dispersal of the Polynesians and their development of complex political systems. In _The Wet and the Dry_ he turns his attention to to Polynesian agriculture, but exhibits the same trait I found most attractive in the earlier book -- a refusal to be constrained by disciplinary boundaries. Kirch combines ethnography and history, social anthropology and archaeology, and draws extensively on the natural sciences, in particular ecology and genetics. The first part, about three quarters of the book, is a detailed ethnographic study of Futunan agriculture. This covers the island ecology and crops, the differences between the dry and wet halves of the island (with a detailed study of one "wet" area), the political economy of agriculture (gender roles, food prestations), and the archaeological record. The second part is a comparative study of agriculture on three other Polynesian islands -- Hawaii, Mangaia and Tikopia -- >from a predominantly archaeo-ecological perspective. The _The Wet and the Dry_ is notable for its illustrations: these are ordinary half-tones, but they are integrated unusually well into the text. A good selection of maps and diagrams is also provided. While much of this material is rather technical -- many anthropologists and archaeologists will find the details of the genetics and ecology of Futunan crops esoteric, for example -- and the subject is ostensibly fairly narrow, Kirch does tackle some "big" questions. He stresses the fundamental distinction between the "wet" and the "dry", between pondfield irrigation and shifting cultivation, and he turns Wittfogel's hydraulic hypothesis on its head, arguing that throughout Polynesia it was the areas incapable of supporting irrigation which developed states and were politically expansive. Another concern is the importance of a long-term, archaeological perspective, which reveals the considerable effects agriculture had on Polynesian island environments even in the prehistoric period. This sort of material should have wide appeal, making _The Wet and the Dry_ of interest to those without a particular interest in Polynesia. -- Disclaimer: I requested and received a review copy of _The Wet and the Dry_ from the University of Chicago Press, but I have no stake, financial or otherwise, in its success. -- %T The Wet and the Dry %S Irrigation and Agricultural Intensification in Polynesia %A Patrick Vinton Kirch %I University of Chicago Press %C Chicago %D 1994 %O hardcover, b&w illustrations, bibliography, index, US$49.95 %G ISBN 0-226-43749-3 %P xxii,385pp %K archaeology, anthropology, agriculture, Polynesia Danny Yee (danny@cs.su.oz.au) 14 April 1995 ------------------------------------------------------------- All book reviews by Danny Yee are available via anonymous FTP ftp.anatomy.su.oz.au in /danny/book-reviews (index INDEX) or URL http://www.anatomy.su.oz.au/danny/book-reviews/index.html ------------------------------------------------------------- Copyright (C) Danny Yee 1995 : Comments and criticism welcome -------------------------------------------------------------